![]() |
Comelec Chair Andres Bautista |
When
I ran into Comelec Chair Andres Bautista recently at the wake of his
uncle-in-law, Aquiles Gaborro, at the Sanctuario de San Antonio, the hacking of
the Comelec website hadn’t still broken out in the news. Political pundits readily
remarked that this hacking, done by a group called Anonymous Philippines, may
be indicative of the loose safeguards for the coming automated elections (ironically, the hackers' message was that security features be installed in the voting machines).
To Chair Bautista, quite a personable fellow, the hacking means one more king-sized
headache to tackle.
That
evening at the repast in the Sanctuario patio, the joke was that he refused to
sit beside this blogger, as he must be by now quite allergic to media,
following the bugbog-cerrado Comelec has been reaping on various issues. Bautista
must also be wary of being misquoted. I can understand how he
feels, and I sought to assure him that his presence at Comelec’s helm helps
secure a bit of badly-needed credibility for it.
XXX
Our
friend Tito Lagdameo naughtily asked me as we lined up for the buffet within
earshot of Andy Bautista, if I agree with what Comelec has been doing, My quick reply: I agree with some, but not
with others. For instance, I fully supported its disqualification (DQ) of Grace
Poe---expertly argued before the Supreme Court by Commissioner
Arthur Lim; but I didn’t like it that
the voter verification paper audit trail (VVPAT or “voter receipt” for short,
mandated now by the SC) won’t be carrying the voter’s name, precinct no., date
of the election and other details needed to make this receipt truly credible.
Bautista replied that had the citizens’ groups, led by former Sen. Dick Gordon, the AES Law’s principal author, clamored for VVPAT last December, there would have been more than ample time to adjust the source code (the command instructions for the vote-counting machines or VCM). But now, to get all those data in, the elections would have to be postponed for two weeks, which can't be allowed to happen, said the poll chief.
Bautista replied that had the citizens’ groups, led by former Sen. Dick Gordon, the AES Law’s principal author, clamored for VVPAT last December, there would have been more than ample time to adjust the source code (the command instructions for the vote-counting machines or VCM). But now, to get all those data in, the elections would have to be postponed for two weeks, which can't be allowed to happen, said the poll chief.
A
query in my mind: those voter’s receipts have been provided for in the AES Law, as
Dick Gordon has repeatedly stressed. Why was it not carried out in the past two
elections? Why do we have to clamor for it before it’s attended to; when there’s
no more time to load those details.
XXX
I
queried the poll chief why he accepted what was from the beginning a frightfully
thankless job, and he replied that he felt it was a way to serve, and that if
he didn’t accept it he could feel sorry in the years ahead why he passed
up this challenge? I mentioned about the
syndicates said to be operating inside the Comelec selling winning posts for a
fee, and Bautista gave indication he was
aware of them. He also opined that while vote-shaving is possible here and
there, operators cannot just move against candidates perceived as doing well in
the surveys. I ventured in return that the general belief is that surveys can
be manipulated, and he shot back, “Do you think Mahar Mangahas can be
bought?” I didn’t have a ready answer
for that, though I cited surveys in past elections which appear to have been less than credible---especially since the lead survey companies are known to have interlocking directorates.
XXX
Bautista
is the son-in-law of my good-looking and ever-glamorous friend Baby Gaborro-Cruz
(her pretty daughter Tricia is Andy’s wife). While we were at the buffet table.
I raised the point being reported in media, though not officially--- that the SC
is mulling leaving the issue of Grace Poe’s qualification to run in the
presidential election “unresolved,” as the private lawyers and Comelec's lawyer opposing Poe’s
candidacy have worried about in their joint MR---and just tackle this DQ issue AFTER THE
ELECTIONS ARE OVER.
This could mean, in the anticipated tightly-contested elections this May, the POSSIBILITY THAT THE SC, THIS TIME SITTING AS THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTORAL TRIBUNAL (as per the Constitution), COULD DISQUALIFY POE AFTER SHE IS ELECTED PRESIDENT.
This could mean, in the anticipated tightly-contested elections this May, the POSSIBILITY THAT THE SC, THIS TIME SITTING AS THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTORAL TRIBUNAL (as per the Constitution), COULD DISQUALIFY POE AFTER SHE IS ELECTED PRESIDENT.
Bautista replied emphatically, “If true, that
plan of the SC could be the one that would bring very serious trouble to the
country.” He stressed that Poe's possible DQ ought to be resolved now, before the elections.
XXX
Recall
that the Comelec en banc had earlier DQed Poe on the twin issues of
citizenship and residency and cancelled her certificate of candidacy. But Poe challenged
Comelec’s DQ before the SC and after five long hearings the SC threw out the DQ and ordered her COC restored---without
an explanation of its decision. Meaning,
the issue of Poe’s eligibility was left unresolved, plus the fact that the 7-5 vote
in favor of restoring her COC did not reflect the majority vote in the
15-member Court, as Senior Magistrate Antonio Carpio pointed out in his
dissenting opinion. Comelec, represented by Commissioner Arthur Lim, and
four private respondents separately filed MRs on this ruling, and the High Court
is supposed to be tackling these MRs during its current summer sessions in
Baguio.
Then
came this unofficial media buzz about the SC’s inclination to just await the
results of the May 2016 elections and let the PET decide Poe’s eligibility with
finality AFTER THE ELECTIONS. This is troubling due to the possibility in these very tight
presidential elections, of her bagging the top post but having to be DQed. Or perhaps, the first question should be, WOULD THE SC JUSTICES HAVE THE GUTS TO DQ AN ELECTED PRESIDENT?
What could happen by then is something visualized by former law dean Amado Valdez in his prefatory statement on the Poe case:. "When the smoke of battle cleared, the foundling had received heer 'fair' share to run for President, no matter that in its wake are remnants of a Constitution shattered and the piece of legislation called R.A. 9225 (the Citizen Retention and Reacquisition Act) torn of its essence."
What could happen by then is something visualized by former law dean Amado Valdez in his prefatory statement on the Poe case:. "When the smoke of battle cleared, the foundling had received heer 'fair' share to run for President, no matter that in its wake are remnants of a Constitution shattered and the piece of legislation called R.A. 9225 (the Citizen Retention and Reacquisition Act) torn of its essence."
XXX
As
I said earlier, Comelec Chief Bautista feels that to postpone resolution of the
Poe issue to after the May elections, where there’s the possibility that she
could win, could spell big trouble---because her being yanked out
of office may not be condone kindly by her followers. I fully agree. There is no
reason why the SC cannot NOW resolve the MRs filed by private respondents Manuelito Luna, Estrella Elamparo, Amado Valdez and De La
Salle University Prof. Antonio Contreras---all of whom support the Comelec’s DQ of Poe.
The SC's decisive more on Poe’s eligibility or none is IMPERATIVE, as the
very life of our Republic would be in grave danger when justices play around even
with the very clear and express wording of the Constitution, as stressed by SC
Justice Arturo Brion in his 147-page dissenting opinion. Dilly-dallying by the SC is not doing us any
good and only opens the magistrates to reports, unfair it may be, of BIG BUCKS CHANGING HANDS.
XXX
In
fact, various political pundits are nearly one in urging the SC to resolve
Poe’s qualification NOW NA, and the historic stand of the 50,000-member strong
Integrated Bar of the Philippines has helped forge this unity among the
lawyers. Ex-Marinduque Rep. Regina Ongsiako Reyes’ protest about her being
recently ousted from her House post owing to her past US citizenship, whereas Grace Poe, until 2012 an American, is allowed to run for President has
also impacted on citizens about the SC’s double standard. Reyes
was ousted several weeks ago by the House Electoral Tribunal in favor of arch-rival Lord Velasco, son of SC Justice Presbitero Velasco who voted with
the Sereno bloc.
Consider the following excerpt from the March
28, 2016 column of Manila Times’ Yen Makabenta, titled, “Not
Whether the High Court will review its decision, it must.” :
“The May elections should put to the test this total contempt for the electorate. It’s not only the intelligentsia that is now questioning angrily the SC decision to allow Grace Poe to run.
Young people (the millennials) and the proverbial man on the street are now wondering aloud why the nation is going through all these contortions and acrobatics, for an ambitious woman whose identity is unknown, and whose Filipino citizenship is unproven.
“We must deal with Grace Poe because she represents a naked and
open challenge to our constitutional system, one that is financed by powerful
business interests who believe that they can buy the presidency. If we do not
stop this assault, our constitutional order could collapse, and the nation will
list until it can find its mooring.
“If Grace Poe succeeds in forcing her way into the balloting in
May, the elections could be turned into a mockery as one justice has warned. We
are in this rut because the Supreme Court has momentarily lost its way. John F.
Kennedy said that “an error does not become a mistake until you refuse to
correct it.” Correcting the errors and averting the mistake is, in essence, the
central message of the dissenting opinions in the SC decision.”
XXX
Philippine Star columnist Federico Pascual, in his March 29 “Postcript”
titled “Why Issue of Poe’s Candidacy Still Lingers,” was just
as emphatic about the need for the SC to
resolve Poe’s eligibility. Said Dick:
“TO RESOLVE the above
confusing decision, there is now the imperative need for the SC to immediately
decide on the pending appeal filed by Rizalito David from a majority decision
of the Senate Electoral Tribunal which ruled that Poe, as a foundling, is a natural-born
Filipino citizen.
“It is in this case
where the citizenship of Poe was directly assailed without regard to whether or
not she made any false representation in her COC for senator in the 2013
elections.
“If the SC rules that
Poe is a natural-born citizen, then that settles this issue once and for all. If
the SC rules that she is not, then the Comelec, on its own or motu
propio or even without any petition, could still disqualify her and
all votes cast for her will not be counted, if the decision is rendered before
the May 9 election since ‘the Comelec will be grossly remiss in its
constitutional duty to enforce and administer all laws relating to the conduct
of elections if it does not motu propio bar from running for
public office those suffering from perpetual special disqualification by virtue
of a final judgment.’
“But what if said
decision disqualifying Poe is rendered after the election and Poe still
gets the highest number of votes and proclaimed as duly elected President by
the Congress of the Philippines? That would be another skirmish in the
Legal and Political Battle of the Century.”
I
Why does the SC "strategize" on election matters?
ReplyDeleteIn my layman's mind, an infant found on the Philippine soil, could not, in the wildest possibility, had been borne elsewhere in the world. Thus, under the principle of Jus Soli, she surely is a Filipina.
On the issue of 7 as majority, the abstention of 3 has two effects: 1) it does not result in a lack of quorum 2) the 3, being neither yes nor no, is equivalent to zero. Therefore, 12 constitutes a quorum, and 7 is a majority of 12.
THUS, I WONDER, "WHY THE DILEMMA?" ...mine is based on common sense and may or may not have legal basis.
nike factory outlet
ReplyDeletelouis vuitton outlet
michael kors outlet
true religion
louis vuitton outlet
louis vuitton
polo ralph lauren
cheap jordan shoes
hollister kids
christian louboutin outlet
louis vuitton bags
jordan retro
toms shoes
michael kors
ray ban sunglasses
hollister clothing store
jordan 8s
louis vuitton outlet
pandora jewelry
beats headphones
replica watches for sale
nike free run 2
burberry outlet online
coach outlet store online clearances
air jordan 13
jordan 3 infrared
louis vuitton bags
air max 90
michael kors handbags
jordan 6
ghd hair straighteners
christian louboutin outlet
designer handbags
michael kors outlet online
kate spade
michael kors outlet online
kobe 9
fitflop sandals
louis vuitton outlet
michael kors handbags
2016.5.31haungqin
20160618meiqing
ReplyDeletemichael kors outlet clearance
timberland outlet
pandora outlet
rolex replica watches
adidas nmd
lacoste shoes
tiffany jewelry
gucci handbags
fitflop uk
cheap jordan shoes
christian louboutin shoes
nike air force 1
under armour shoes
coach outlet
michael kors watches
supra for sale
nike free run
hollister clothing
nfl jerseys wholesale
nike huarache white
toms outlet
coach outlet store
adidas supercolor
cartier watches
true religion jeans
michael kors outlet online
michael kors outlet
adidas trainers
chaussure louboutin
nike free flyknit
lacoste outlet
kate spade handbags
coach factory outlet
bottega veneta outlet